How is fishing like aquaculture? Trick question. It’s not.

Posted by marti@kahea.org at Mar 26, 2011 12:00 AM |
Filed under:
Does an industrial fish farm count as fishing? Apparently, NOAA says “yes.” To permit an experimental open ocean fish farm operation, NOAA is looking to grant a corporation (Kona Blue Water Farms on Hawai`i Island) a fishing permit and call its fish farm cages “a new, unlisted gear type.”
How is fishing like aquaculture?  Trick question.  It’s not.

Kona Blue Aquapods - lost at sea

UPDATE April 2, 2011: Kona Blue Aquapods lost at sea!  Operators "decided" to sink the two aquapods because they were surprised at the rough seas in the Alenuihaha Channel.  One pod sunk, one drifted away.  We are concerned about entanglements and damage to corals. Operators prepared to try again next month.  Permit has not yet been issued.  Read more in the news.

A personal favorite in the comments on the news story in the Honolulu-Star Advertiser: "No way to reattach the tether", "no way to sink the cage". Those aren't problems with the design so much as they are symptoms of a deeper failure of vision: "No clue about how to deal with easily foreseeable occurrences".

Does an industrial fish farm count as fishing?  Apparently, NOAA says “yes.” To permit an experimental open ocean fish farm operation, NOAA is looking to grant a corporation (Kona Blue Water Farms on Hawai`i Island) a fishing permit and call its fish farm cages “a new, unlisted gear type.”
If granted, this would be the first time a fishing permit is used for the purpose of factory fish farming in U.S. federal waters. Many communities are worried about the precedent this might set. Commercial fishing interests have shown increasing interest in legally defining offshore fish farms a “fishery.”

This approach has left little room for meaningful review by agencies and the general public. Little consideration is being given to the long term and potential cumulative impacts of this decision.  But we should not let the federal government’s absurdly short comment periods prevent us from demonstrating our support for proper stewardship of our ocean resources. Submit your comments to NMFS right now.
Document Actions
Filed under:
Thomas Tizard says:
Apr 07, 2011 02:49 AM
"Fish Farms" are nasty, destructive to the wild populations, either fed on animal waste or using up wild-fish feed, have nowhere near the quality of wild fish, and pose a danger of inter-breeding with the wild population. No arguments on their behalf can overcome the real and threatened harm they pose.
kehaulani kea says:
Apr 07, 2011 11:34 AM
It is time to pause here, to question the impact of such a proposal. All too often decisions are made in haste, driven by fear or greed, which later impact negatively upon planet. I have read similar statements as expressed here by Mr. Tizard. I certainly do not want another GMO food introduced that will not support life.
Professor Aloha says:
Aug 03, 2011 10:09 PM
As the world's population continues to explode, I think all of us must find more sources for growing food. We have become a very spoiled society--that is unsustainable. If you buy anything at the grocery store that isn't grown locally---especially chicken, beef, pork and certain vegetables like corn--they've already been GMO'd and you are consuming and encouraging that very thing which you appear to be fighting. If the whole world would grow their own organic food--great, but it isn't likely to happen. Aquaculture can be much more sustainable than all of the other "meats" you are eating. Just depends on the company. Not bad to put pressure, but you can't live in a bubble....people need to eat. You should support sustainable aquaculture, rather than assume that it is all bad.
Dana G. Moss, N Kohala says:
Mar 29, 2013 10:12 PM
There incapacity to deal with the currents on there first try is the evidence that shows how poorly planned there project is at the get go. Sailors from all over the world sail here and go through the Alenuihaha channel for the first time. And say this is the roughest water they have ever experienced in there travels. And NOAA wants to take a chance with our local resources. I say no! The Kamachi Fish Farm has already introduces a new bacteria into our waters that can make people very sick and or kill them. were inundated with environmental screw up's already like fire ants and koki frogs ect. Now someone wants to play with the balance of the ocean even more. Do not do this! Enough all ready. Just think of all the sharks they will kill to protect there cages. As they put it "aggressive shark management" statement at the meeting in Kawaihae at the mac nut factory building about two years a go. Plus the market is mostly Japan for there sales. Jobs are very minimal and they said they would be targeting younger people for there work force according to the statement made at a meeting.
Add comment

You can add a comment by filling out the form below. Plain text formatting. Web and email addresses are transformed into clickable links. Comments are moderated.

Donate

Empower grassroots efforts to protect Hawaiʻi with your donation today.

$
E-mail Sign-up
Follow Us